Your Trusted Lawyers for Winning Litigation & Appeals

An appeal is a legal process in which a party asks a higher court to review a lower court's decision for legal or procedural errors. Appellate courts generally review the existing trial court record rather than conduct a new trial or hear new evidence.

Depending on the case, an appeal may challenge errors involving the application of law, admission or exclusion of evidence, jury instructions, sentencing, or other rulings that affected the proceedings. The reviewing court may affirm, reverse, vacate, modify, or remand the decision based on the applicable law and standard of review.

To appeal a court decision, you must first determine whether the order or judgment is appealable, which court has jurisdiction, and the applicable filing deadline. Many appeals begin by filing a notice of appeal, while certain cases require an application for leave or permission to appeal.

After an appeal is properly initiated, the process generally involves preparing the appellate record, reviewing transcripts, identifying legal issues, and submitting written briefs. Oral argument may also be scheduled.

The requirements differ between state and federal courts, so reviewing the judgment and procedural history promptly is essential.

Both civil and criminal cases may be eligible for appellate review, depending on the judgment, court, and applicable law.

Common types include criminal convictions and sentences, business disputes, insurance litigation, property disputes, and other civil judgments. Some interlocutory or non-final orders may also qualify for immediate review under specific rules.

Not every court order is immediately appealable, and some matters require permission to appeal. The available grounds and scope of review depend on the issues raised, the existing record, and the applicable standard of review.

Brownstone Law focuses exclusively on appellate representation in state and federal courts. Its appellate attorneys review trial court records, evaluate potential legal errors, research applicable law, and prepare written appellate arguments.

Depending on the case and agreed scope of representation, appellate services may include filing required briefs and motions, preparing reply briefs, presenting oral argument when scheduled, and evaluating options for rehearing or further appellate review.

The initial evaluation helps determine whether an appeal is available, which issues may be raised, and what steps are necessary to protect applicable deadlines.

Yes. An appellate court may reverse or vacate an entire judgment, but it may also grant partial relief or leave the original decision unchanged.
Possible appellate outcomes include affirming the judgment, reversing a ruling, vacating a conviction or sentence, modifying the decision, or remanding the case for additional proceedings.

For example, an appellate court may vacate one criminal conviction while affirming other convictions. A remand does not automatically mean a new trial; the lower court must follow the appellate court's instructions.

The outcome depends on the legal issues presented, the record, and the governing law.

Appeal deadlines vary depending on the court, case type, judgment, and applicable procedural rules. Common deadlines include:

• Federal criminal appeals: A defendant generally has 14 days after entry of the judgment or order being appealed to file a notice of appeal.
• Federal civil appeals: The deadline is generally 30 days after entry of judgment, although some cases have a 60-day deadline and certain motions may affect the filing period.
• Michigan appeals: Many appeals of right must be filed within 21 days of the relevant judgment or order, but different rules and deadlines apply to certain proceedings.
• U.S. Supreme Court review: A petition for a writ of certiorari is generally due within 90 days of the judgment or order being reviewed, subject to applicable rehearing rules and extensions.

Missing an appellate deadline can limit or eliminate available options. The specific judgment and procedural history should be reviewed promptly.

To evaluate an appeal, an appellate lawyer typically needs the following documents:

• Judgment or court order: The decision being challenged.
• Court docket: A record of filings, hearings, and orders in the case.
• Notice of appeal: If an appeal has already been filed.
• Written court opinions: Any decisions explaining the lower court's reasoning.
• Trial or hearing transcripts: Records of relevant court proceedings, if available.
• Relevant motions and case documents: Including sentencing materials or plea agreements in criminal cases, when applicable.
• Previous attorney information: Contact details for trial or prior appellate counsel.

For U.S. Supreme Court matters, the date of the lower court's judgment and information about any petition for rehearing are particularly important because they may affect the filing deadline.

An appellate attorney can identify additional documents needed after reviewing the available case information.

Brownstone Law uses flat-fee arrangements for appellate representation, with the agreed attorney fee established before the covered work begins.

The fee depends on the nature of the appeal, the record, the legal issues involved, and the scope of services required. Representation for a direct appeal, rehearing, or U.S. Supreme Court petition may involve separate engagements.

During the case evaluation, the firm can review the matter and explain the proposed scope of representation and applicable legal fees. The written agreement should identify which services and expenses are included.