U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

Appeals in the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit

The Eleventh Circuit sits in Atlanta and hears appeals from the federal district courts of Florida, Georgia and Alabama. It is the court of appeals in which Brownstone Law has the deepest file, because the firm is based in Florida and because its Georgia practice feeds the same court. The circuit has a distinctive set of local rules, a heavy criminal docket, a strong preference for deciding appeals without oral argument, and a body of precedent on sentencing, suppression and habeas that governs every federal case in the three states. This page describes how an appeal moves through the Eleventh Circuit, the local requirements that differ from the national rules, and the issues the firm has briefed there most often.

The court and its districts

The Eleventh Circuit was created in 1981 when Congress divided the old Fifth Circuit. It inherited the former Fifth Circuit’s precedent through Bonner v. City of Prichard, which adopted all decisions handed down before October 1, 1981, as binding. That history matters in practice, because older Fifth Circuit cases remain controlling authority in the Eleventh Circuit and must be cited as such.

Nine district courts feed the circuit: the Northern, Middle and Southern Districts of Florida; the Northern, Middle and Southern Districts of Georgia; and the Northern, Middle and Southern Districts of Alabama. The Middle District of Florida, headquartered in Orlando with divisions in Tampa, Jacksonville, Fort Myers and Ocala, and the Southern District of Florida in Miami produce the largest share of the circuit’s criminal appeals. The Northern District of Georgia in Atlanta produces most of the civil and white collar work. The court sits principally in Atlanta, with regular sittings in Jacksonville, Miami and Montgomery.

The circuit’s twelve active judgeships and its senior judges decide appeals in rotating three-judge panels. Published opinions bind later panels under the prior panel precedent rule, which the Eleventh Circuit applies strictly: a panel may not overrule a prior published decision even if it believes the decision was wrong, and only the en banc court or the Supreme Court can change the rule. Unpublished opinions are not binding but may be cited as persuasive authority under Eleventh Circuit Rule 36-2.

Local requirements that differ from the national rules

The Eleventh Circuit supplements the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure with its own rules and internal operating procedures, and the clerk’s office enforces them by rejecting non-compliant filings.

The Certificate of Interested Persons. Eleventh Circuit Rule 26.1-1 requires every party to file a Certificate of Interested Persons and Corporate Disclosure Statement, known as the CIP, listing in alphabetical order every person and entity with an interest in the outcome, including the trial judge, all attorneys, all parties and any corporate parents. The CIP must appear at the front of every brief and must also be completed on the court’s web-based system. An omitted or deficient CIP is among the most common reasons a brief is returned.

Brief contents and order. Rule 28-1 prescribes the order of a principal brief in more detail than the national rule, including a statement regarding oral argument, a statement of the standard of review for each issue, and a specific format for the statement of the case. Rule 28-5 requires record references by document number and page as the record appears on the district court docket. Rule 32-4 sets the length limits, which track the national 13,000-word limit for principal briefs, and requires a certificate of compliance.

The appendix. Rule 30-1 requires the appellant to file an appendix containing specified documents from the district court record, including the docket sheet, the indictment or complaint, the judgment, the orders appealed from, relevant transcript portions and any jury instructions at issue. The appendix is separate from the brief and is filed electronically, with paper copies on request.

Expedited criminal briefing. Rule 31-4 shortens the briefing schedule in criminal appeals, and extensions are granted sparingly. Counsel who takes over a criminal appeal from trial counsel should calculate the brief deadline from the date the record is complete, not from the notice of appeal.

Mediation. Civil appeals in which all parties are represented are referred to the Kinnard Mediation Center under Rule 33-1, and a Civil Appeal Statement must be filed within 14 days of docketing. Criminal and pro se appeals are not mediated.

Oral argument and disposition

The Eleventh Circuit decides most appeals without oral argument. Rule 34-3 permits the court to decide an appeal on the briefs where the panel unanimously concludes that argument is unnecessary, and the court’s internal operating procedures route appeals through a screening process in which a staff attorney or a judge identifies cases suitable for non-argument disposition. Criminal sentencing appeals, Anders appeals and many habeas appeals are decided this way, often with an unpublished opinion. A party who believes argument is warranted should say so in the statement regarding oral argument and explain why.

The court issues its decision by opinion or by unpublished per curiam, and the mandate issues seven days after the time to petition for rehearing expires or after the denial of a petition. Petitions for rehearing and rehearing en banc are governed by Rule 40 and the Eleventh Circuit’s own Rules 40-1 through 40-11, which include a requirement that an en banc petition state with particularity the precedent with which the panel decision conflicts.

Issues the Eleventh Circuit decides most often

The Eleventh Circuit’s docket is dominated by criminal appeals from Florida’s three districts, and its precedent on several recurring issues shapes how the firm briefs them.

Sentencing. The circuit reviews guidelines calculations de novo for legal questions and for clear error on facts, and reviews the sentence as a whole for substantive reasonableness under a deferential abuse of discretion standard. It has a developed body of law on career offender predicates, the categorical approach, loss calculation in fraud cases, and the application of the firearm and drug guidelines. The firm’s sentencing page describes the framework in detail.

Suppression. The circuit applies the mixed standard of review to suppression rulings and has decided many cases on vehicle stops, consent, the good faith exception and the scope of warrants in the digital context. Florida’s traffic enforcement practices make Rodriguez v. United States prolonged stop claims a frequent issue.

Habeas and 2255. The Eleventh Circuit hears a large volume of appeals from the denial of 2254 petitions and 2255 motions, and most require a certificate of appealability. The circuit applies the deferential standard of 28 U.S.C. 2254(d) rigorously, has a strict body of law on AEDPA timeliness and the tolling effect of Florida post-conviction motions, and has addressed many successive petition applications after Johnson and other retroactive decisions.

Restitution and forfeiture. Financial crime prosecutions in the Southern and Middle Districts of Florida produce frequent appeals over restitution amounts, loss causation and forfeiture money judgments.

Brownstone Law in the Eleventh Circuit

The firm’s files include 61 matters with a lead document from the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. The issues briefed most often in those matters are sentencing error, ineffective assistance of trial counsel, restitution and forfeiture and the AEDPA limitations period. Counts come from the firm’s own matter index and describe experience, not results.

Robert L. Sirianni, Jr. is admitted to the Eleventh Circuit bar and the firm’s office in Winter Park sits within the Middle District of Florida. The firm handles direct criminal appeals, civil appeals, and appeals from the denial of habeas relief in the circuit, and it files petitions for rehearing en banc and for certiorari where the panel decision presents a question the full court or the Supreme Court should resolve.

Matters the firm has briefed in the Eleventh Circuit

Each line describes one matter in the firm’s files: the court, the year of the most recent document, the county where the record shows one, and the issues the firm’s brief raised. The descriptions say what was argued, not how the matter ended. Past results do not predict future results.

  • M.M. (Eleventh Circuit, 2026). Argued that the district court erred in granting summary judgment on Appellant’s bankruptcy discrimination claim under 11 U.S.C. § 525(a) by improperly relying on its deficient racial discrimination analysis to find the bankruptcy was not the sole cause of termination.
  • C.M. (Eleventh Circuit, 2026). Argued that the district court violated due process by imposing sanctions against counsel without providing notice that sanctions were being considered or an opportunity to be heard.
  • J.L. v. United States (Eleventh Circuit, 2026). Argued that the district court erred in applying the two-level “sophisticated means” enhancement under the Sentencing Guidelines.
  • M.B. v. United States (Eleventh Circuit, 2025). Argued that the client received ineffective assistance of counsel in the district court.
  • B.B. (Eleventh Circuit, 2024). Argued that the District Court erred in dismissing Appellant’s Excessive Force claim where the arrest was a violation of the Appellant’s constitutional rights.
  • C.K. v. United States (Eleventh Circuit, 2024). Argued that the court erred in dismissing the appellant’s case due to her failure to retain an attorney for the estate II.
  • R.W. v. United States (Eleventh Circuit, 2022). Argued that prosecutorial misconduct and ineffective assistance of council tainted the plea agreement negotiations and sentancing.
  • D.P. v. United States (Eleventh Circuit, 2022). Argued that a Judgment of Acquittal is proper when the Government failed to prove that a defendant in a conspiracy case is not involved with anyone charged in the indictment and a defendant’s criminal activity took place in a different state than the other individuals charged in the indictment.
  • N.H. (Eleventh Circuit, 2021). Argued that the district court erred in dismissing a pro se Title VII claim under the Civil Rights Act of 1964 for failure to follow court discovery orders, when the party (1) diligently responded to court orders, (2) was repeatedly ignored by defense counsel, and (3) tried to provide all discovery documents requested.
  • M.R. v. United States (Eleventh Circuit, 2020). Argued that the district court erred when it did not review a forensic accounting before making sentencing calculations pursuant to the Guidelines resulting in an improper sentence.
  • S.C. v. United States (Eleventh Circuit, 2019). Argued that the district court held that the the client failed 1 to demonstrate actual innocence, and that he did not show that counsel was ineffective for failing to make such argument.
  • J.R. v. United States (Eleventh Circuit, 2016). Argued that the district court clearly erred in finding that the client had failed to identify race-neutral reasons for attempting to exercise peremptory strikes on all of the black members of the venire.

Frequently asked questions

How long do I have to appeal to the Eleventh Circuit? Fourteen days from entry of the judgment in a criminal case and 30 days in a civil case, or 60 days if the United States is a party. The notice is filed in the district court. Those periods come from the national rules, and the Eleventh Circuit enforces them.

Will there be oral argument? Most likely not. The Eleventh Circuit decides the majority of its appeals on the briefs. Argument is more likely in civil cases with complex records and in criminal cases presenting an unsettled legal question.

What is a CIP? The Certificate of Interested Persons and Corporate Disclosure Statement, a list of every person and entity with an interest in the case that the Eleventh Circuit requires at the front of every brief and on its web form. It is used to screen for judicial recusal.

Does the Eleventh Circuit follow old Fifth Circuit cases? Yes. Decisions of the former Fifth Circuit issued before October 1, 1981, are binding precedent in the Eleventh Circuit.

Can an unpublished Eleventh Circuit opinion be cited? Yes, as persuasive authority. It does not bind a later panel.

Where does the court sit? Primarily in Atlanta at the Elbert P. Tuttle Courthouse, with sittings in Jacksonville, Miami and Montgomery.

Past results do not predict future results. Every matter turns on its own record. This page is general information, not legal advice about any particular case.

California Third District Court of Appeal Eleventh Circuit United States Court: 3 States, Top Guide
DMCA Protection Status