Law Suit Filed Against Board of County Commissioners in Orange County to Stop Unconstitutional Ballot Calling for reducing mayor Jacobs term of office to two years

Law suit filed against Bill Cowles and board of county commissioners in Orange County, Florida to stop unconstitutional ballot calling for partisan local elections

On July 29, 2014, the BCC voted to place the subject Ballot on the November election cycle as a referendum. If the referendum passes during the November 2014 general election, the effect will be to revise Section 605 of the Orange County Charter and reschedule the next election of all Charter offices elected countywide from 2018 to 2016.

The phrase all Charter offices elected countywide is materially misleading.

If the referendum passes, only one (1) county official, Orange County Mayor Teresa Jacobs, will have a term of office cut in half and be forced to run for election again in two years, rather than four. Jacobs, who is unopposed for reelection this year and, therefore, is now deemed under Florida law to be reelected, would otherwise have a new term of office from 2014 through 2018. However, the subject Ballot singles out only the office of Jacobs  that is, the office of Orange County Mayor  and reduces Jacobs next term of office by two years.

Orange County Mayor Teresa Jacobs

Brownstone Law, an appellate firm based in Winter Park, Florida challenges the legality and validity of a ballot initiative petition in Orange County that misled registered voters as to the purpose of the amendment. Brownstone filed an injunction to stop the ballot from being placed on the November 2014 voter forms.

Brownstones Managing Partner Robert Sirianni says In my judgment, it is the deceptive ballot summary and ballot title that do not reveal that the mayors office is the only office affected  they are hiding the ball. The Ballot entry uses vague, generic, and deceptive terms to hide the actual intent and effect of the new law. The Ballot will deceive voters by failing to disclose that Jacobs will have not a full four-year term of office, but rather a term cut in half.

Voters, such as Plaintiff Marcos Sayago, are reasonably led to believe by Florida election law and the county charter that Jacobs has been reelected for a new four-year term; however, if the subject Petition passes during the same election on November 4, 2014, the legitimate belief of the voters is undermined, and the ballot title and summary does not and will not correct or dispel that belief.

Sayago alleges that the subject ballot title and summary mislead voters into believing that more than one Charter office elected countywide will be subject to the rescheduling of elections and truncation of terms. He also claims that the Ballot failed to state with specificity, and otherwise failed to disclose, that the only office which will be impacted by the amendment to Section 605 of the Orange County Charter is that of Jacobs. 

Click below for more case details:

Petition Citizens For Informed Government

Brownstone’s Complaint for Injunctive Relief and Declatory Relief

About Brownstone Law Firm

Brownstone Law Firm is a Florida-based appellate law firm that can appeal cases in both state and federal courts. Brownstone Law attorneys are able to handle civil and criminal appeals that may include but are not limited to drug appeals, medical fraud, white collar crime, insurance defense, business litigation and more. Learn more here: nbrownstonelaw.wpengine.com

Speak with an appellate lawyer.